Online vehicle trading code
Preamble
Online vehicle trading is here to stay. For commercial car dealers, too, the Internet has now become the main way of placing ads and establishing contact.
The initiators of this code (ADAC e.V., the Zentrale zur Bekämpfung unlauteren Wettbewerbs e.V. (Centre for Combating Unfair Commercial Practices), the Zentralverband des deutschen Kraftfahrzeuggewerbes e.V. (ZDK: umbrella organisation of the Germany automobile industry), the Internet-Anzeigenbörsen AutoScout24 GmbH (AutoScout24) and mobile.de GmbH (mobile.de) agree that future success is directly dependent on maintaining high quality in online vehicle trading. The trade's capital is user satisfaction. We can only ensure this if online vehicle adverts have maximum transparency and if transactions are processed properly.
So it is extremely important that we try to avoid nuisances that aim to cheat innocent consumers or gain unfair advantage in the car dealer market. So, at the 2007 German Transport Forum, the decision was taken to draw up binding, common standards of conduct for this sector.
The code that has been drawn up for this purpose is aimed at the online automotive sector (hereinafter: dealers), their associations (hereinafter: dealer associations), consumer associations and any online advertising mart operator who provides advertising opportunities to the car trade (hereinafter: advertising marts) and complies with the rules that have been laid down.
Objective
The code aims to provide joint opposition to those factors that jeopardise secure, high-quality online vehicle trading. Therefore, the overriding goal is, as far as possible, to ensure that there is security for buyers, protection against attempts to defraud and fair competitive conduct amongst online dealers. Having binding rules of conduct will ensure that there is transparency, and actively and jointly combat the misuse of the opportunities that online vehicle trading provides.
The code aims to safeguard and promote the great benefits of online vehicle trading for all users. In particular, the code is intended to increase buyer and seller satisfaction and to ensure that they deal with one another in a trustworthy way. This will help protect consumers and competition. Common rules of conduct that apply to all those involved in online vehicle trading will form an appropriate basis for this.
The initiators have, therefore, drawn up rules of conduct that aim to ensure that online vehicle trading is correct. Those who accept the code will follow the rules laid down here. Dealers, advertising marts and associations will also communicate the code on their website so that all users of online vehicle trading can easily view the code at any time.
Dealers and dealer associations
1. General
Dealers undertake to comply with the code and to help communicate it amongst their customers. They will refrain from any conduct that jeopardises the security and quality of online vehicle trading. User satisfaction is their primary objective. To this end, dealers will ensure that their ads are up to date. Vehicles should be removed from the mart as soon as possible after they have been sold. Vehicles which do not exist or which cannot be purchased (decoys) shall not be advertised in the mart.
2. Legal Guidelines
Dealers will comply with all obligations deriving from legal guidelines. This includes the following obligations in particular:
- Dealers will provide the following information which is required by Article 5 of the German Telemedia Act (so-called "Impressumspflicht" ["legally required information"]) or, at least, enable it to be accessed via a direct link:
- the name and the address for service of process of the provider, and in the case of corporate bodies also the authorised representatives;
- details which enable swift electronic contact and immediate communication (e.g. phone, email) with the provider, including the email address;
- the commercial register, associations register, partnerships register or cooperative societies register in which the provider is registered, and the corresponding registry number;
- the VAT ID number (if there is one) in compliance with Article 27a of the German VAT Act;
- the Commercial ID number ["Wirtschafts-Identifikationsnummer"] (if there is one) in compliance with Article 139c of the German Fiscal Code.
- Dealers will provide additional information as required under Article 5a (3) (3) of the German Unfair Competition Act (UWG) and Article 1 (1) of the German Pricing Act (PAngV). Under these laws, end prices should be provided in the relevant price field, which, in particular, have to include VAT and other pricing components (particularly destination charges). Ads with prices that are clearly incorrect or misleading are not permitted (on this, see also under Showing Prices).
- Dealers will provide, to the extent that the German Ordinance on Consumer Information about Fuel Consumption and CO2 Emissions in New Cars (Pkw-EnVKV) prescribes this, details about fuel consumption and about the CO2 emissions and the CO2 efficiency class including a graphic display, and, at the same time, will also make reference to detailed information on official fuel consumption and on specific CO2 emission. This can be taken from the guidelines that can be accessed on the DAT Deutsche Automobiltreuhand GmbH (DAT) website (at http://www.dat.de/leitfaden/LeitfadenCO2.pdf). These guidelines should be referred to in the advert in relation to information on consumption and emissions.
- In cases where a remote sale contract is concluded, dealers shall note the extensive obligations imposed by the German Distance Selling Act both prior to and after the conclusion of the contract, particularly the duty to provide information about rights to cancel the contract and return the item purchased.
3. Complying with the terms of use of advertising marts
Dealers will comply with the provisions of the terms of use of advertising marts, particularly to refrain from publishing products that are not permitted in adverts published there.
4. Vehicle categories
Dealers undertake to truthfully assign the vehicles they have advertised according to the vehicle categories – new vehicles, used vehicles, single day registrations, employees' cars, demonstration vehicles, classic vehicles – defined in this code's Glossary and to refrain from placing ads for vehicles in incorrect categories.
The definitions form part of this code and are attached to it as an annex. They shall also be made available in a suitable form for users to access.
5. Full and truthful details
In their adverts, dealers must describe their vehicles truthfully and fully. They are liable for the details being complete and accurate. Dealers shall include in the detailed description all of the vehicle's important characteristics which are essential for making a buying decision, including any significant damage to the vehicle.
This particularly includes the duty to declare any significant damage that has not been repaired, which must be described fully and truthfully. The details provided ought not to trivialise the damage, and the damage should be documented in a photo. A vehicle may only be advertised as "accident-free" if the dealer is convinced that this is the case and if they are able and willing to vouch for this in law.
The real total mileage must also be specified correctly. If this is not known or needs to be ascertained, it should be indicated that the mileage given is only that which has been read from the clock. If the vehicle is fitted with a replacement engine, this should be declared. The dealer must also declare if the vehicle is an EU import or a vehicle that was not originally manufactured for the German market.
Dealers should not use any misleading details. They should particularly refrain from advertising a vehicle under an inappropriate heading or providing an incorrect mileage or an incorrect first registration date. Dealers are responsible for the accuracy of the data they use. They should particularly try to avoid entering incorrect details by accident (e.g. typing errors), and should correct any such errors as soon as they are found.
If it is not explicitly pointed out that a vehicle will need to be first ordered or procured, it should be assumed that the vehicle is in stock (or in the warehouse) and that it is available to be viewed at the premises of the dealer advertising it either already or within a short period of time (up to a maximum of 24 hours).
It should also be indicated if the vehicle is a rental vehicle, taxi or driving school vehicle.
6. Showing prices
Dealers undertake to provide correct and truthful prices. The price given must comprise the actual gross end price including VAT and all other costs. These particularly include destination charges. Therefore, it is not permitted to advertise or make an offer for a vehicle labelled "plus destination charges". This also applies if the destination charges are clearly shown. The costs must, rather, be included in the end price from the very start and entered in the price field provided for this purpose.
The gross end price should include the costs of transport to the dealer's location. If the dealer's location is different to the location of the vehicle, this difference should be clearly indicated in the ad.
These principles apply to all vehicles and particularly to export vehicles unless they are displayed in separate categories (e.g. for export vehicles).
7. Using photos
In the case of used vehicles, dealers should basically only use their own pictures or original photos, and in the case of new vehicles, preferably their own pictures which, in the case of vehicles which are in stock, show the advertised vehicle. In the case of new vehicles, where a dealer uses third-party catalogue pictures, this should only occur if the necessary permissions to use copyrighted material have been granted, and the different source (e.g. catalogue picture) of the pictures should be clearly indicated.
8. The sales process
Dealers should not request any advance payments. The deal should be done on a reciprocal basis. Once the agreement has been successfully concluded, the buyer pays the purchase price and, in return, receives the vehicle, the vehicle keys, plus the registration certificate Parts 1 and 2, or the car's registration document and the proof of ownership letter.
Advertising marts
1. General
Advertising marts strive for dealers and other advertisers to comply with legal provisions and the obligations of the code. They make the code available for users to access.
2. Clarification
Advertising marts will provide their users with easily accessible information about the possible risks involved in buying vehicles, as well as basic rules of conduct for using the website securely. In particular, they should warn against providing any advance payments and recommend that their users do the deal on a reciprocal basis. They should also indicate other sources of information, such as the website www.sicherer-autokauf.de. Advertising marts should also provide further information for commercial suppliers, explicitly pointing out dealers' obligations.
3. Definitions of terms and mandatory fields
Advertising marts should use the categories drawn up for this code: new vehicles, used vehicles, single day registrations, employees' cars, demonstration vehicles, classic vehicles, damaged vehicles. They should make the definitions of these terms available to their users in a suitable way.
For placing vehicle ads, advertising marts should provide the following mandatory fields that users must fill in when placing the ad:
- Brand, model (it is possible to enter 'Other');
- Category (used vehicles, new vehicles, single day registrations, employees' cars, demonstration vehicles, classic vehicles, damaged vehicles);
- Price (as end price);
- In the case of all vehicles except new vehicles: first registration date and mileage;
- Energy labels (in the case of new vehicles, single-day registrations and demonstration vehicles)
Advertising marts should explicitly indicate on the detailed information pages that the prices given must be gross end prices including VAT and all other costs.
4. Supplier identification and trial period
When dealers are registering on their platforms, advertising marts should request their business registration documents. During a period of at least two months after initial registration (trial period), advertising marts should randomly check dealers' adverts in particular and, if necessary, make personal contact with the dealers.
5. Reports / sanctions
Advertising marts should take reasonable measures to identify untrustworthy adverts and suppliers, and exclude these from their platforms. In particular, they should keep communication channels open, which permit consumers and dealers to immediately report any contravention of the law or of this code. Advertising marts should follow up such reports and remove, as quickly as possible, any ads that clearly contravene the law or this code and which are not corrected upon request.
Within the realms of what is technically feasible and reasonable, advertising marts should deploy technical systems to look specifically for certain types of contravention. They should randomly check whether dealers' details are complete and, where they are incomplete, they should notify the dealers.
Where contraventions occur, advertising marts should take suitable measures against the advertisers who are not acting in compliance with the rules and urge them to comply with the rules in future. Where contraventions continue, advertising marts should increasingly impose sanctions until, eventually, banning the advertiser.
6. Product enhancements
The measures described shall not prevent advertising marts from enhancing their products. In enhancing their products, marts should aim to continue to promote security and quality.
Consumer and dealer associations (associations)
Associations should actively aim to disseminate information to help raise awareness of the obligations that derive from this code in their organisations. Dealer associations should aim to make the acceptance of this code a binding industry standard for all members of their respective organisations, and should take suitable measures to ensure that the code is complied with and put into practice. As far as possible, associations should help members of their organisations to implement the code. Where contraventions of the code occur, associations should notify the dealers and advertising marts concerned and take suitable internal action under the legal requirements to ensure the code is complied with.
Informing users
Users can only be effectively protected against fraudulent or anti-competitive adverts if they themselves collaborate, if they are informed about security measures and if they implement those measures.
Those adopting this code therefore regard it as a general task to keep users informed as well as possible so that they know and comply with, for example, the following security rules:
- Read the adverts carefully and in full!
- If you are interested in buying, make sure that the details have been explicitly reconfirmed beforehand.
- At least in the case of used vehicles, it is usually a good idea to view the vehicle prior to agreeing to buy it and, if possible, to test drive it in order to verify that the details provided by the dealer are accurate.
- Cross check that the details in the ad match the information actually provided in the vehicle's papers.
- If you are purchasing, you should make no advance payments, but make the deal in a reciprocal fashion.
- Only use secure payment methods by means of which the recipient can prove that they have actually taken receipt. In particular, do not use cash transfer services, such as Western Union or MoneyGram.
Further sources of information for users, such as www.sicherer-autokauf.de are being developed and disseminated.
Cooperating with the authorities and payment system providers
Those adopting this code should strive to reinforce cooperation with supervisory and investigative agencies in order to ensure that illegal activities are effectively prosecuted.
They should also attempt to get payment system providers to take suitable measures to prevent their services being abused in the course of criminal acts.
Enhancing this code
Those initiating this code aim to regularly enhance the code in order to adjust it to new developments and new forms of misuse. The intention is to regularly exchange practical information about the use of the code and about new methods of misuse that come to light.
Glossary
Online vehicle trading code definitions
1. Categorisation
● New vehicle
The vehicle has not yet been registered, either in Germany or elsewhere, and the vehicle is from the latest range of models being traded and is strictly no more than 12 months old.
Or:
The vehicle has not yet been registered, either in Germany or elsewhere, and the vehicle is from the range of models that immediately precedes the latest model range being traded and is strictly no more than 12 months old. When naming the car, the previous model's attribute should be referred to.
If a vehicle meets the requirements of a new vehicle but is more than 12 months old, this should be indicated (e.g. manufactured September 2012).
It is mandatory to indicate this in accordance with the Pkw-EnVKV (see Glossary point 5).
● Single-day registration (single day registrations in the sense of the category definition may also be short registrations)
The vehicle is a single-day registration if it has only been registered with a dealer's business with the registration not exceeding 30 days and the vehicle is one of the latest range of models being traded and is strictly no more than 12 months old.
Or:
The vehicle is a single-day registration if it has only been registered with a dealer's business with the registration not exceeding 30 days and the vehicle is from the range of models that immediately precedes the latest model range being traded and is strictly no more than 12 months old. When naming the car, the previous model's attribute should be referred to.
A manufacturer's guarantee essentially begins on the first registration date. If the vehicle is not immediately registered when delivered, the guarantee can also begin earlier.
If a vehicle meets the requirements of a new vehicle but is more than 12 months old, this should be indicated (e.g. manufactured September 2012).
It is mandatory to indicate this in accordance with the Pkw-EnVKV (see Glossary point 5).
● EU import/re-import
The vehicle was originally not intended for the German market and is being brought (back) to the German market from another EU country. Such vehicles may have a first registration date elsewhere in the EU (usually to a brand dealer); new vehicles from elsewhere in the EU, too, can be brokered by the dealer in the vehicle mart, i.e. the purchase agreement for the vehicle is made between the German customer and a non-German vehicle dealer under the brokerage of the dealer advertising in the vehicle mart.
● Used vehicle
The vehicle was or is registered and has been used in public transport as intended.
● Demonstration vehicle
The vehicle is registered to a dealer and is only used for demonstration purposes. This will be a used vehicle in the sense of the legislation governing the sale of goods.
It is mandatory to indicate this in accordance with the Pkw-EnVKV (see Glossary point 5).
● Employee's car
The vehicle may not be more than 24 months old at the time of the advert and it has been registered uninterrupted for a maximum of 13 months and the registration is restricted to one owner.
● Classic vehicle
A vehicle which is at least 30 years old and meets the requirements to have an H-registration.
● Car
A vehicle that is used to transport people and has no more than eight seats in addition to the driver's seat; the categorisation made in the vehicle's papers (Class M1 – see vehicle documents code "J") is crucial.
● Commercial vehicle
A vehicle used to transport goods or people; the categorisation made in the vehicle's papers (Classes M2, M3, N1-3 – see vehicle documents code "J") is crucial; construction machinery, agricultural and forestry machines or vehicles.
● Motorcycle
An engine-powered bike, including trikes and quads
● Export vehicle
A vehicle which is essentially destined for export from the Federal Republic of Germany.
● Stock vehicle (or warehouse vehicle)
Vehicles which are available at the dealer's location, either immediately or within a short period of time (up to a maximum of 24 hours).
2. Price
In the "End price" field, prices should be specified in compliance with Article 5a (3) (3) UWG in conjunction with Article 1 PAngV, i.e. in particular, gross prices including the VAT that applies in each case plus all other ancillary and accessory costs (e.g. destination charges). Price breakdowns are only permitted in the "Description" section.
These principles apply to all vehicles, including to export vehicles, unless they are displayed in separate categories.
3. Mileage
In the "Mileage" input field, the vehicle's actual mileage should be specified; anything else is explicitly restricted. (In the case of replacement engine machines with little mileage or where there are other circumstances that indicate that the total mileage does not match the current display on the milometer, such facts should be referred to in the "Description" section).
4. First registration (date)
The vehicle's actual first registration date, including at least the month and year, should be specified (if a vehicle was registered in December 05, the first registration date should be entered as 12/05 and not as 01/06).
5. Details of fuel consumption and CO2 emissions
The definition in the Pkw-EnVKV applies to new cars. According to the Pkw-EnVKV, new cars are those which "have not yet been sold for some purpose other than that of resale or delivery". Full (legally required) information is to be given about consumption and emissions in the case of new cars, day and short registrations, and demonstration vehicles.
As a minimum, the fuel consumption in the combined test cycle and the official specific CO2 emissions in the combined test cycle are to be indicated, along with the fuel type on which the calculation was based. The CO2 efficiency class including a graphic display must also be stated where required. It is recommended that the test cycle values indoors, outdoors and combined are given, as well as the official specific CO2 emissions in the combined test cycle. The following information is essential:
"Further information on official fuel consumption and official specific CO2 emissions in new cars are available in the "Guidelines on Fuel Consumption, CO2 Emissions and Power Consumption in New Cars", which is available free of charge at all sales outlets and from the "Deutsche Automobil Treuhand GmbH" at www.DAT.de.
6. Vehicle descriptions
● Manufacturer guarantee
The manufacturer guarantee is the guarantee given by the manufacturer themselves. A distinction is drawn between this and the vendor's legally regulated warranty for defects. Where relevant, the reduction of the manufacturer's guarantee term, particularly in the case of new EU vehicles, should be indicated if this guarantee is reduced by more than 14 days while an offer is being made for the vehicle.
● Damaged vehicle
A vehicle with significant (prior) damage, e.g. because of a traffic accident, fire, hail or water, no matter whether the vehicle is to be sold repaired or unrepaired. Appropriate information is required; in the case of damage that has not been repaired; this should be documented with pictures. Normal wear and tear and slight damage do not come under the term "damaged vehicle". Slight damage is only limited external (paintwork) damage, but not other (body) damage, even if there are no further consequences and the work required to repair it is very limited.
● Defects
A vehicle with an unrepaired technical, electronic or visual defect, where there is no damage from an accident (e.g. clutch, gears, air-conditioning, etc.); such items should be separately indicated in the vehicle description.
Code of 16.09.2008 in the 30.04.2013 version